Hidden Risk in CAGR: Why Higher Returns Can Mean Higher Volatility
(NISM)

The National Institute of Securities Markets (NISM) is a public trust established in 2006 by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), the regulator of the securities markets in India. The institute carries out a wide range of capacity building activities at various levels aimed at enhancing the quality standards in securities markets.

Blog

One thing we all love is speed. We love it when groceries are delivered in 10 minutes, we want to reach our destinations faster, and, of course, we want to grow our wealth faster through higher returns.

“Nobody wants to get rich slowly,” Warren Buffett once said. I think about this often.

In our cars, we have a speedometer that tells us exactly how fast we are going. While it shows our accurate speed, it fails to show us how much additional risk we take on as we accelerate.

Let’s look at the math of a 50km drive on a highway.

Speed (km/h) Time Taken (min) Time Saved Risk Level
40 75 Low
60 50 25 min Moderate
80 37.5 12.5 min Manageable
100 30 7.5 min Elevated
120 25 5 min High
140 21.4 3.6 min Lethal

Notice how the incremental time saved becomes negligible compared to the surge in risk:

  • Accelerating from 40 to 60 km/h saves a significant 25 minutes (High utility).

  • Accelerating from 60 to 80 km/h saves another 12.5 minutes (Moderate utility).

  • However, pushing from 120 to 140 km/h is drastically more dangerous.

 
At that speed, your braking distance has increased significantly, your margin for error is nearly zero, and a small pothole can become a life-threatening event.

All this risk for what? To arrive just 3 minutes and 36 seconds earlier??

Your portfolio works in the same way

Your portfolio works like that highway journey. Most investors focus solely on the CAGR (the speedometer), but they ignore the Volatility (the risk of a fatal crash).

Here is how different portfolio mixes performed over the last 9 years. Notice how volatility drops when you add uncorrelated assets into the mix:

Scenario Equity % Debt % Gold % CAGR Volatility (Risk) Volatility (Risk) change %
A 50 25 25 13.2% 8.8% 0%
B 60 20 20 13.5% 10.1% 15%
C 70 15 15 13.8% 11.6% 31%
D 80 10 10 14.1% 13.1% 49%
E 90 5 5 14.3% 14.7% 67%
F 100 0 0 14.4% 16.3% 85%

Source: NSE, AMFI, Bloomberg | Data is from: 07 Nov 2016 to 31 Dec 2025
Equity: Nifty 50 TRI, Debt: 10Y G-Sec, Gold: Nippon India ETF GoldBees

Think about this:

  • Would you accept 41% higher risk (volatility) for just a 0.6% extra CAGR? (Comparing C to F)

  • Would you accept 85% higher risk for a 1.2% extra CAGR? (Comparing A to F)

 
This isn’t merely due to the recent outperformance of gold.

Look at the difference between Scenario D and Scenario F, where the allocation to gold is only 10%. To generate just 0.3% of extra CAGR, the risk (volatility) increases by 24%.

Your specific allocation will vary based on your risk appetite, goals, and age.

However, this analysis highlights the hidden dangers of chasing that last bit of return. Before you floor the accelerator, ask yourself if the marginal gain is worth the risk of a fatality.

Or in terms of investing, Is the extra return high enough to lose your mental peace?

Author: Nihit Kshatriya, Head of Investor Relations, Capitalmind Mutual Fund.

Follow Us

Subscription Subscribe to our newsletter and receive a selection of cool articles every weeks

    Related Blogs

    Blog ...
    09th Apr 2026
    The Importance of Personal Financial Planning

    As we move through different stages of life, our financial responsibilities also change. In the early stage, we do not…

    Blog ...
    08th Apr 2026
    Reading the market’s language: why technical analysis belongs in every financial professional’s toolkit

    Many readers of this blog already have a professional relationship with markets. You have cleared NISM certifications, completed structured courses,…

    Blog ...
    07th Apr 2026
    Investor Participation: Multiple Factors at Play

    Acknowledging that financial awareness is only a first step could herald multi-dimensional policy-regulatory initiatives The Investor Survey 2025, released by…

    © 2026 National Institute of Securities Markets (NISM). All rights reserved.